I tend to be highly critical. Especially when it comes to music, (specifically, the lyrics).
If the lyrics are vague, don’t make sense, or not as “theologically sound” as I’d like them to be, I count them as “stupid.”
I think one thing that I am forgetting is that music, specifically lyrics, are poetry.
To bash poetry, I would argue in my case, puts the sin on my shoulders.(?)
Expressing love for God through the form of poetry seems to make much more sense than doing so through a “logical system.”